When I first started getting into RSS, I used NewsGator. Probably the coolest thing about using NewsGator as my aggregator was that it allowed me to synchronize my feed folders in Outlook to my Pocket PC, meaning that I could read my feeds offline. Even cooler was that anything that I read while away from my computer would be marked as read when I synchronized my Pocket PC.
This worked well for me for awhile, but over time a few things became apparent:
- Outlook is just damn slow. 2003 especially. (Chris Pirillo’s right on this one)
- The Pocket PC Inbox application only supports plain text, with no image support. Formatting is stripped.
- ActiveSync, while much better than it used to be, gets flaky and downright unstable when synchronizing a large number of folders. I’m not talking Scoble-like 1000′s of feeds/folders, but more like anything over 100. At that point it gets really flaky.
This is really a shame, because I’ve yet to come across any other way to synchronize the same set of RSS feeds in XP as well as on my Pocket PC. But I eventually became so frustrated with fighting with Outlook and ActiveSync that I decided there must be something better. I decided to divide my RSS subscriptions into “desktop” and “Pocket PC” feeds; I tend to scan more on my desktop, but read in depth on my Pocket PC, so I sorted accordingly.
I’ve been through a bunch of different readers on my Pocket PC since then, most recently Ilium Software’s NewsBreak reader for Pocket PC. I was using the 1.0 trial version, which, while a nice reader, has a number of shortcomings. To be fair, they have apparently released a 1.0.1 version, so many of the problems I’m about to list may have already been sorted out. Anyhow, here were my problems with NewsBreak:
- Navigation between feeds required stylus taps; it can’t be done with navigation buttons
- The application if left running would fairly regularly hang my Pocket PC in a running state, killing my battery dead and requiring me to restore from a backup (if I had a recent one) or reinstall all software (this has happened to me twice)
- Because of the above bug, I could not set it to automatically synchronize, so had to remember to manually do so each time I docked my Pocket PC
This eventually became tedious, so I decided to see if there were any better readers available for Pocket PC. The one I heard mentioned again and again is called Egress.
So far it looks great; navigation can be accomplished solely with navigation buttons, and it apparently will download and cache inline images (I haven’t seen another Pocket PC aggregator that would do that). So I’m giving it a go. I’ll let you know how it goes!
Please note: I've moved my active blogging over to a new site, called Jason Clarke - Infinite Bass Line. I will leave this site up indefinitely, but if you're interested in my latest posts please consider visiting the new site.
by Ellen Craw
07 Jul 2005 at 09:00
Jason, we’re trying hard to reproduce the hanging problem you point out, and just have not been able to. Can I get some more information from you about your Pocket PC model, and what other third-party software you have installed? I’d also like to send you a newer version of NewsBreak to try. Can you contact me at the email address I’m including (or http://www.iliumsoft.com/site/custserv/contactsp.php?Ellen )? I’d really like to find out what’s causing what you’re seeing. Thank you.
Pingback
by J.P.C. - Jason Clarke » Using Blogs to Expand Your Company’s Product Support Capabilities
07 Jul 2005 at 12:04
[...] xie to post her request in what would otherwise appear to be a hostile environment. Link: Ellen’s Comment [...]
by Tim
13 Oct 2005 at 13:38
You may also want to consider NewsMob.com.
NewsMob is a web based RSS aggregator that works with your Pocket PC, sync or live, to provide access to your news anytime, anywhere.
by Jason
15 Oct 2005 at 01:15
Thanks for the suggestion, Tim. I checked it out, but it looks like there are quite a few hoops you have to jump through before you get the offline reading experience on the Pocket PC. I’ll file it away for future reference though.